Steeped in history and bursting with fascinating attractions and exhibits, Sheffield should be high on your list of places to visit when exploring Yorkshire. It is world-renowned for its history of steel production but in more recent years, the ‘Steel City’ has also become something of a foodie hotspot.
The birthplace of the UK’s craft beer revolution and home to five Michelin star restaurants, Sheffield has secured an enviable position on the culinary map. Boasting an eclectic array of independent eateries, Sheffield offers something for everyone when it comes to eating and drinking. With so many superb restaurants, cafes, gastro pubs and more to choose between, it can be difficult to decide where to eat when visiting.
For decades now, pizza has been a firm favourite amongst Brits for both restaurant dining and takeaways so to kick start our Sheffield foodie guide, we’re focusing on just that. Here are five of the best places to get pizza in Sheffield…
Where to get the best pizza in Sheffield
Napoli Centro
343 Glossop Rd, Broomhall, Sheffield S10 2HP
Napoli Centro is a cosy little pizza restaurant in Sheffield’s Broomhill area. Independently owned and a popular choice with students, this snug little eatery serves authentic Neopolitan pizzas and a range of traditional Italian sides. Made from slow-proofed dough and topped with ingredients sourced from Campania, pizzas at Napoli Centro are cooked in under 90 seconds. This short, sharp burst of extreme heat results in a light and airy crust with that slightly charred finish synonymous with Neopolitan style pizza.
The crust here is undeniably good but it’s the fresh ingredients that make it a winner! Worlds apart from your standard takeaway pizzas, theirs are topped with all the deliciously authentic meats, cheeses and vegetables you would expect to find at a traditional pizzeria in Italy, including Calabrian nduja, smoked provola cheese, ricotta, gorgonzola, kalamata olives, porchetta and prosciutto. We particularly like the sound of their ‘Sophia Loren’ which is topped with caramelised red onion, goat’s cheese, smoky pancetta and crushed walnuts (£10.50).
Proove
261 Fulwood Road, Broomhill, Sheffield S10 3BD
Tel: 0114 294 518
Proove Pizza have venues in just three UK locations. Proove’s Sheffield restaurant is immensely popular with both locals and visitors. Offering top-notch Neopolitan pizza and a laidback dining experience, this cracking pizza place is nestled just on the edge of Sheffield city centre. Their hand-stretched dough is made using the finest 00-grade Caputo flour before being topped with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection in wood-fired ovens.
The menu at this pizza restaurant in Sheffield includes some truly mouthwatering topping combinations and a great selection of vegan-friendly options. Go veggie with their La Contadina – a green pea base sauce topped with mozzarella, sautéed cabbage, capers, breadcrumbs and crushed pistachios or, for a meaty mouthful, opt for the Carni which is toed with San Marzano D.O.P tomatoes, mozzarella, pepperoni, nduja, fennel salami, ham and chillies.
If pizza isn’t your thing or you fancy something extra to enjoy alongside one, Proove also serve a fantastic range of small plates. Bruschetta, Arancini, Crochette and Caprese salad and many other small plate options are all available to tantalise your taste buds.
Dos Amigos
96 – 98 The Dale, Woodseats, Sheffield S8 0PS
Tel: 0114 221 5097
Located in Woodseats, Dos Amigos is an independent restaurant serving authentic Mexican and Italian cuisine. Founded by two friends, this superb family-friendly restaurant is just a ten-minute drive from Sheffield city centre and the perfect venue for a family celebration or get-together.
Known locally for their generous portions and reasonable prices, Dos Amigos combines two cuisines to make what can only be described as an eclectic menu of international favourites. There’s something to suit everyone here so it’s a great place for groups and large parties with differing tastes. For those seeking a bit of spice, their Mexican offerings include fajitas, burritos and enchiladas. Italian cuisine lovers can choose from a number of kinds of pasta, risottos and, of course, pizzas.
There are six toppings options for their homemade pizzas as well as three different calzones. Priced from just £10.25 for a 12″ pizza, it’s pretty good value. Expect firm favourites like Margherita and Pepperoni in addition to a couple of spicier, Mexican inspired versions.
Bloo 88
182 West Street, Sheffield City Centre, Sheffield S1 4ET
Tel: 0114 270 6264
Housed in a beautifully renovated 19th-century building, Bloo 88 is a spacious city-centre venue offering craft cocktails and freshly made pizzas. This place is all about the vibes so the menu isn’t as extensive as other pizza places in the area. However, their stunning interiors, beautiful cocktails and super crispy pizza bases make this eatery one of the most popular pizza spots in Sheffield.
Prepared using the finest locally sourced ingredients and then baked in their stone oven, pizzas here are delightfully thin and crisp, making them the perfect accompaniment to Bloo 88’s boozy creations. Alongside their range of pizzas, this swanky Sheffield establishment also serves a range of starters, nibbles and sides to complement. By day, this place is a chilled eatery boasting retro interiors and simple food. By night, it’s a must-visit cocktail bar frequented by the city’s young partygoers and Instagram influencers.
If you want to avoid the hustle and bustle of the city centre at night, then Bloo 88 offer daytime dining from 4 pm Monday to Thursday and from 12 pm Friday to Saturday. At weekends, we recommend booking in for their Bottomless Brunch as diners get 90 minutes to enjoy a pizza or a portion of doughballs plus unlimited drinks.
The Italian Kitchen
349 Ecclesall Road, Sharrow, Sheffield S11 8PF
Tel: 0114 266 4168
If you’re looking for a great Italian restaurant in Sheffield then look no further than The Italian Kitchen. This family-run independent eatery specialises in fish and seafood but their pizzas and calzones are out of this world. The restaurant interiors are simple yet contemporary as the focus at The Italian Kitchen is all on the food. Cosy and welcoming, this intimate dining venue is ideal for both families and couples looking for quality food and a laidback ambience.
Hand-rolled and stone-baked to order, their thin and crispy pizzas start at just £9 for a classic Margherita and there are ten different topping combinations to choose from. However, it’s their calzones that really set them apart from other pizza restaurants in Sheffield as they allow customers to create their own. For £14, you can have tomato, mozzarella plus four additional fillings of your choosing. This crisp parcel of deliciousness is then topped with either Tomato & Chilli, Tomato & Garlic or Bolognese sauce. Nom nom!
Craft & Dough
1A Kelham Square, Kelham Island, Sheffield S3 8SD
Tel: 0114 276 2803
What goes better with pizza than a good craft beer? The team behind Craft & Dough at Kelham Island know that this is a match made in heaven and their business model is based upon this perfect pairing. Open Wednesday to Sunday, this place makes fresh pizzas daily to serve alongside a long list of award-winning craft beers from breweries including Magic Rock, SALT and, of course, Keelham Island. If beer isn’t your thing then be sure to check out their cocktail menu as these go equally as well with a crispy dough oozing with molten cheese.
If it’s a laidback evening of no frills eating and drinking, then Craft & Dough is the place for you. Rustic industrial interiors and chilled vibes combine to make this the perfect little spot for catching up with friends over a slice and a pint. On the menu you’ll find nine different pizzas in addition to a superb selection of tasty sides and indulgent desserts. Our pizza of choice would most certainly be the Piggy Smalls (£10) which is topped with pork, bacon, bacon bits and those retro favourites – Frazzles! Pizzas start at just £8 and for an additional 50p you can upgrade to a garlic-brushed crushed.
Nether Edge Pizza Company
144 Abbeydale Rd, Nether Edge, Sheffield S7 1FF
Tel: 0114 250 8037
Nether Edge Pizza Company first opened in 2014 and has since won various awards for its wood fired pizzas. With its relaxed dining dining area and open kitchen, this excellent pizzeria on Abbeydale Road is simple yet incredibly charming. Independently owned and super friendly, Nether Edge Pizza Company is perfect for family meals and chilled weekend dining. They’re dog friendly too so your four-legged companion can join you for a pizza in Sheffield!
There are plenty of pizza choices here and prices start at just £7.50 for a traditional Margherita. Many of the pizzas on their menu are named after areas in Sheffield such as the ‘Broomhill Brie’ and the ‘Meersbrook Meaty’ and they’re all made using fine Italian ingredients. Therir Vegan menu is also pretty extensive with an impressive 7 vegan pizza options plus garlic breads available. You can make your own ‘pizza perfection’ if you can’t find anything on the menu that tickles your fancy but with such a varied range of toppings available, we’re sure that you will!
